Reeves joined the Wildcats coaching staff in December of 2019, coming to Abilene from Ole Miss where she was a volunteer assistant coach. 

Reeves served as an assistant coach and the defensive coordinator for the Wildcats through her first three seasons before being named the Associate Head Coach in June of 2022. Caty has been integral to bringing advanced analytics to the program as they have increased their win total in each season. 

She was with the Rebels for just the 2019 season, but was a part of a coaching staff that led the team to fifth-place finish in the SEC as well as hosting, and winning, an NCAA Regional. Prior to Ole Miss, Caty was the head coach at Oklahoma Wesleyan for six years. During her tenure, she led the Eagles to a program-record 36 wins in 2016 as well as producing 18 first-team all-conference players, two Conference Pitcher of the Year awards, and three Conference Player of the Year awards. Reeves began her coaching career in the Southland Conference when she spent one year at McNeese overseeing the catchers while also assisting with hitting and pitching for the Cowgirls.

Not only does Reeves have an extensive coaching career, but a great playing career as well. She spent four years playing at California Baptist University when they were competing at the NAIA level in the GSAC conference. During her time at CBU she spent time at catcher, first base, as well as a designated player. Over her four years the team amassed a 251-22 record winning conference championships all four years, as well as winning an NAIA national championship in 2009. 

She was also a star in classroom earning NAIA Scholar Athlete honors twice and a CoSIDA Academic All-American nod once.